top of page

Cooling Design Weather: Keep Coincident Conditions and Humidity Cases Together

Oct 16
5 min read
Original warm-orange and blue weather illustration separating a hot dry-bulb case from a cooler humidity-led case.

A load worksheet contains the design dry-bulb temperature from one weather column and the design humidity from another. The resulting air state may be physically possible, but the sheet no longer represents either published design condition. Before selecting equipment, preserve the paired weather inputs and determine which case governs sensible load, outdoor-air enthalpy load and moisture removal.


This matters particularly for systems with substantial outdoor air. A cooler, more humid condition can impose a greater moisture burden than the hottest dry-bulb case. The worked comparison below uses invented weather values to isolate that effect. It is not weather data for a named city, a recommended design percentile or a complete building load calculation.


1. Retain the meaning of each weather column


A dry-bulb design entry is commonly accompanied by a mean coincident wet-bulb temperature. A wet-bulb design entry can have its own mean coincident dry-bulb temperature. A dehumidification entry can instead use design dew point, corresponding humidity ratio and mean coincident dry bulb. These pairs describe different statistical selections from the weather record.


The ASHRAE climatic-design explanation explains these relationships and the role of the separate cooling, wet-bulb and dehumidification conditions. Its percentile description also clarifies that an annual 0.4% threshold corresponds to approximately 35 hours in an average 8,760-hour year. It does not promise that exactly 35 occupied hours will exceed the value every year.


Use the project-approved, current data source for the actual station and edition. The ASHRAE Weather Data Center identifies the 2025 Handbook data and tools for examining coincident conditions and their underlying distributions. Retain the station name, elevation or pressure basis, publication edition, chosen percentage and whether the statistic is annual or monthly.


A mean coincident value is conditional statistical information. It is not necessarily the largest possible companion value, and it does not eliminate the need for a separate humidity assessment. Copy the complete column heading into the basis of design so a later reviewer can reconstruct what was selected.


2. Define the airside comparison boundary


For this example, consider only the incremental outdoor-air treatment burden relative to a specified indoor reference state. Use a dry-air mass flow of 1.50 kg/s at every case, atmospheric pressure 101.325 kPa, and an indoor reference of 24°C with humidity ratio 0.00950 kg water/kg dry air. Keep these quantities fixed to isolate the weather effect.


The approximate moist-air enthalpy equation is h = 1.006 × T + W × (2,501 + 1.86 × T), where T is in °C, W is kg/kg dry air, and h is kJ/kg dry air. The 2025 ASHRAE Handbook psychrometrics chapter provides the property relationships and dry-air mass basis. The indoor reference enthalpy from this equation is 48.3276 kJ/kg dry air.


The comparison heat rate is Qoutdoor = mda × (houtdoor − hindoor), in kW. The excess incoming moisture rate is mwater = mda × (Woutdoor − Windoor), in kg/s. Multiplying the latter by 3,600 expresses kg/h. This is a weather-driven airside comparison, excluding fan heat, duct gains, heat recovery and liquid-condensate energy corrections.


It is also not the entire cooling-coil duty. A real coil may need to cool outdoor air below the indoor reference, absorb room loads or serve a mixed-air stream. Define those additional boundaries separately before using a result to select equipment.


3. Calculate two paired hypothetical weather cases


Two hypothetical weather pairs at 1.50 kilograms per second of dry air yield 29.01 and 51.36 kilowatts of outdoor-air treatment burden and 10.51 and 57.14 kilograms per hour of excess moisture respectively.

Original hypothetical cases at 101.325 kPa. Indoor reference: 24°C and W = 0.00950 kg/kg dry air. Loads compare each outdoor state with that reference; they are not complete coil selections or city weather data.


Case A represents a dry-bulb-led cooling check: 38°C dry bulb with 23°C thermodynamic wet bulb. At 101.325 kPa, the moist-air property calculation gives W approximately 0.011447 kg/kg dry air. Treat these as one intact pair.


Case B represents a humidity-led check: 25°C dew point with 31°C coincident dry bulb. At the same pressure, its humidity ratio is approximately 0.020081 kg/kg dry air. Dew point fixes vapor pressure, and the selected atmospheric pressure is needed to obtain humidity ratio. Treat these as the second intact pair.


Using the unrounded calculated properties, Case A has h = 67.6660 kJ/kg dry air. Its incremental outdoor-air heat rate is 1.50 × (67.6660 − 48.3276) = 29.01 kW. Its moisture burden is 1.50 × (0.0114470 − 0.00950) × 3,600 = 10.51 kg/h.


Case B has h = 82.5668 kJ/kg dry air. Its corresponding heat rate is 1.50 × (82.5668 − 48.3276) = 51.36 kW. Its moisture burden is 1.50 × (0.0200811 − 0.00950) × 3,600 = 57.14 kg/h. Although Case B is 7 K cooler in dry-bulb temperature, its outdoor-air heat burden is approximately 77% higher and its moisture burden is more than five times larger.


These differences follow from the supplied example values, not a general climate multiplier. In another location, the governing condition and size of the difference can change. A real selection review may also need a separate high-enthalpy or design-wet-bulb pair; the two illustrative cases do not replace that review.


4. Show what happens when the columns are crossed


Suppose the worksheet takes the 38°C dry bulb from Case A and the 0.020081 kg/kg humidity ratio from Case B. The combined state has h approximately 89.8702 kJ/kg dry air and an outdoor-air heat rate of 62.31 kW. Moisture remains 57.14 kg/h because the humidity ratio and dry-air mass flow remain unchanged.


This constructed case is 10.96 kW above Case B’s heat burden. It is neither original pair, and its frequency of occurrence has not been established. Calling it the published design condition would make the calculation’s provenance incorrect, even though the psychrometric arithmetic is valid.


A designer may deliberately adopt a combined-extremes stress case where the project’s risk assessment justifies it. If so, label it explicitly, document why it is required and avoid attaching the source table’s percentile to the new combination. Equipment selections and commercial allowances should make that extra requirement visible rather than hide it inside an unexplained weather input.


5. Carry each case through the equipment and controls review


The outdoor-air comparison alone cannot identify the final selected capacity. Review the building’s coincident internal and envelope loads, the amount and condition of air entering the coil, required leaving humidity, available chilled-water or refrigerant conditions and the control mode. A humidity-led case can coincide with lower sensible demand, making modulation and overcooling relevant.


Trane’s outdoor-air unit application guidance discusses separate entering-weather conditions and the possibility that peak enthalpy occurs below the maximum outdoor dry bulb. Apply the selected equipment’s own rating and selection rules; a nominal cooling capacity does not establish its leaving humidity at every input state.


If an energy-recovery device is present, calculate its leaving state under each case using applicable performance, leakage and operating assumptions before passing the result to the cooling coil. If airflow changes with occupancy, rerun the mass flow as well. Constant outdoor volume at different temperatures does not imply constant dry-air mass flow, which is why this example deliberately held mass flow fixed.


6. Make the design-weather record auditable


Keep one line per operating case with its complete weather pair, derived humidity ratio and enthalpy, pressure basis, airflow basis, source reference and purpose. Show the resulting airside heat and moisture burdens in separate columns. Attach manufacturer selections for the required cases and record which condition governs each equipment or control decision.


Nexora’s matched-condition coil SHR guide provides the next check: compare available sensible and latent capacity at the same specified inputs. That comparison is stronger when the weather assumptions arriving at the selection are already traceable.


For a structured path from design conditions to outdoor-air loads, airflow and coil duty, use the paid Cooling Load Design Handbook. Its practical load and equipment-selection workflow supports the calculation record. Obtain the actual climatic tables and manufacturer performance from their authorized sources; those data are not included in the handbook.



Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page