Cooling-Tower Range and Approach: Compare Conditions Before Diagnosing Performance

AI-generated illustrative scene, not a product screenshot or a completed-project photograph. The worked calculation below uses explicit example inputs.
A cooling tower is reported as healthy because it still cools the water by five degrees. That observation is incomplete. Five degrees describes the range between entering and leaving water; it does not say how cold the leaving water is, or how close it is to the entering-air wet-bulb temperature. A useful trend review keeps these quantities separate.
The purpose here is to organize a thermal comparison. It is not a water-treatment procedure, a fan-staging instruction or a certified tower acceptance test. Use the tower manufacturer’s permitted operating envelope and the site’s approved procedures. Never change water distribution, fan operation or treatment controls solely to reproduce an illustrative example.
Write the three temperatures before the two differences
SPX defines approach using cold-water temperature and entering-air wet bulb. Its technical explanation distinguishes that approach from the hot-to-cold water range. The first record should therefore contain the hot-water inlet temperature, cold-water outlet temperature and representative entering wet bulb, all with timestamps and measurement locations.
Range = hot-water temperature − cold-water temperature
Approach = cold-water temperature − entering-air wet-bulb temperature
Approximate water-side heat rejection = mass flow × specific heat × range
Temperature differences may be written in kelvins or degrees Celsius with the same numerical value. The absolute readings still need an explicit scale. For heat balance, use a mass flow and suitable fluid properties. The common water approximation is useful for a transparent check, but it is not a substitute for the measurement and property requirements of a formal test.

Hypothetical steady states, not a performance test or operating target.
Original example: equal range, different result
Assume steady water flow of 20 kg/s and specific heat of 4.18 kJ/(kg·K), with negligible differences between inlet and outlet water mass flow for this simplified calculation. Case A has hot water at 35°C, cold water at 30°C and entering wet bulb at 26°C. Case B has hot water at 38°C, cold water at 33°C and the same 26°C entering wet bulb.
Case A range = 35 − 30 = 5 K; approach = 30 − 26 = 4 K
Case B range = 38 − 33 = 5 K; approach = 33 − 26 = 7 K
Water-side heat rejection in each assumed case = 20 × 4.18 × 5 = 418 kW
Both cases reject the same calculated heat under these assumptions, but Case B supplies warmer water. The unchanged range does not establish unchanged tower capability. Conversely, the larger approach does not identify a failed component: fan state, water distribution, air recirculation, load history and sensor errors must be reviewed before assigning a cause.
Weather can change the interpretation again
Now consider Case C with the same 38°C hot and 33°C cold water but entering wet bulb at 29°C. Its range remains 5 K and its approach is 4 K. Comparing only cold-water temperature would make Case C look worse than Case A; comparing only approach would make them look identical. Neither comparison, alone, is a normalized capacity test. Manufacturer performance data are needed to account for the combined operating conditions.
The entering wet bulb must represent air actually reaching the tower, not merely a distant weather-station report. Local recirculation and the measurement position can change that boundary. Preserve the original readings and describe where they were taken; do not silently substitute regional weather data for a missing local measurement.
Build a matched operating-condition record
For each comparison window, record cell availability, fan operating state, water flow, heat load, hot and cold temperatures, entering wet bulb and stable-period duration. Flag startup, staging and rapid load changes rather than merging them with a steady baseline. If flow or wet bulb is missing, state that the comparison cannot isolate thermal performance.
A useful next action is a focused evidence request: obtain the selected tower performance curve at the measured load, flow and entering-air condition, then ask the responsible specialist to reconcile the observed cold-water temperature. This is more specific than an instruction to clean the tower based only on a high approach.
The maintenance checklist pack is a related aid for organizing inspection records. It is not presented as a tower-rating program or proof of the assumed 418 kW result. Keep the calculation, measurement limits and follow-up question together so a later reviewer can distinguish a useful signal from a confirmed diagnosis.
Continue the calculation review
Sources and calculation basis
Primary references checked on 27 October 2026. The worked examples and diagrams are original illustrative calculations, not manufacturer selections or project approvals. Apply the stated limitations and the requirements governing the actual project.

Comments