top of page

Cooling-Tower Heat Rejection: Add Compressor Heat Before Comparing Tons

Oct 14
4 min read
Cooling-Tower Heat Rejection: Add Compressor Heat Before Comparing Tons — original Nexora engineering illustration

A chiller schedule and a cooling-tower quotation can both say “400 tons” without describing the same heat rate. Refrigeration capacity, condenser heat rejection and nominal tower capacity must first be placed on a common basis. Otherwise, adding compressor heat can still produce the wrong comparison because the final conversion uses the wrong kind of ton.


The practical review starts in thermal kilowatts. Identify the evaporator load, identify the compressor energy that reaches the condenser, and calculate the heat-rejection duty. Only then translate the result into the units used by the supplier. The original example below demonstrates that reconciliation; it does not select a tower model.


1. Name the two tonnage bases


The NIST conversion table defines a refrigeration ton, TR, as 12,000 Btu/h, approximately 3.51685 kW. It describes a heat-transfer rate, not electrical input. A chiller delivering 1,400 kW of evaporator cooling therefore delivers 1,400 / 3.51685 = 398.1 TR.


A manufacturer's nominal cooling-tower ton can use a different convention. The SPX Marley MCW technical bulletin, engineering-data note 3, bases its nominal tons on water entering at 95°F, leaving at 85°F, an entering-air wet-bulb of 78°F, and 3 US gpm per ton. That is a stated rating condition, rather than an unconditional site capacity.


Using the familiar approximate water equation, heat rate = 500 × US gpm × temperature difference in °F, this convention represents 500 × 3 × 10 = 15,000 Btu/h per nominal ton, approximately 4.396 kW. The factor 500 combines water density, specific heat and time conversion; exact fluid properties slightly change the result.


Keep separate spreadsheet columns for “evaporator TR,” “heat rejection kW” and “nominal tower tons at stated conditions.” A column headed only “tons” invites a 25% basis error before equipment performance has even been considered.


2. Establish the condenser heat boundary


Trane's cooling-tower training material, printed page 5, explains condenser rejection as evaporator load plus compressor input. It also distinguishes hermetic-motor input from the shaft input of an open-motor arrangement. The relevant energy is what actually enters the condenser heat balance.


Do not add the entire plant electricity reading to the evaporator load. External motor and drive losses may leave elsewhere. Condenser-water pump heat belongs in a wider water-loop balance when applicable; tower fan electricity is not automatically heat added to the circulating water. Heat recovery introduces another outgoing heat path. Request the selected chiller's condenser duty when available and record what that figure includes.


For the following simplified example, assume steady operation, a 1,400 kW evaporator load and 280 kW of hermetic compressor input, all ultimately rejected through the water-cooled condenser. Ignore heat recovery, auxiliary heat and losses to the surroundings. Thus Qcondenser = 1,400 + 280 = 1,680 kW. The matching example COP is 1,400 / 280 = 5.00.


3. Convert the same result two different ways


Expressing 1,680 kW in refrigeration-ton equivalents gives 1,680 / 3.51685 = 477.7 TR-equivalent of heat rejection. This is a valid unit conversion if the label explicitly says refrigeration-ton equivalent. It is not 477.7 nominal tower tons under the 15,000 Btu/h convention.


On that nominal convention, the equivalent quantity is 1,680 / 4.39607 = 382.2 nominal tons. The same 1,680 kW therefore corresponds to two different numerical tonnages. Neither number changes the physical duty. Calling both simply “tower tons” destroys the information needed to compare them.


The nominal-equivalent figure is smaller than the chiller's 398.1 TR even though the condenser rejects more heat than the evaporator absorbs. There is no thermodynamic contradiction: one nominal tower ton represents more heat per hour than one refrigeration ton. This is why comparing the bare numbers can be misleading in either direction.


Original heat-balance diagram: 1,400 kW evaporator load plus 280 kW compressor input equals 1,680 kW condenser rejection, equivalent to 477.7 refrigeration tons or 382.2 nominal tower tons on the stated rating basis.

Illustrative steady-state balance, excluding auxiliary heat and heat recovery. The nominal-ton conversion is a rating-basis reconciliation, not a tower selection at project conditions.


A tempting error is to calculate 477.7 TR-equivalent and then ask for 477.7 nominal tower tons without explaining the basis. At the nominal rating condition, that number represents approximately 2,100 kW, which is 25% above the calculated 1,680 kW. Any actual design allowance should be explicit and justified, rather than hidden inside a unit mismatch.


4. See when the numbers happen to match


Repeat the example at the same 1,400 kW cooling load but with 350 kW compressor input. The matching COP is 4.00 and rejection is 1,750 kW. Its heat-rejection factor is 1,750 / 1,400 = 1.25, whereas the COP-5 example had a factor of 1.20.


Now 1,750 / 4.39607 = 398.1 nominal-ton equivalents, numerically matching the 398.1 refrigeration tons of cooling. This equality follows from the chosen COP and the two tonnage definitions. It does not mean a one-for-one tonnage rule applies to every chiller or every tower selection. A universal 1.25 multiplier would also erase the actual compressor-performance difference between these examples.


5. Cross-check the water-side duty


Return to the 1,680 kW case. Suppose the proposed tower water temperatures are 35.0°C entering and 29.5°C leaving, giving a 5.5 K range. Assume water specific heat of 4.18 kJ/(kg·K) and density of 995 kg/m³ at the representative condition.


The required mass flow is 1,680 / (4.18 × 5.5) = 73.08 kg/s. Volumetric flow is 73.08 / 995 = 0.07344 m³/s, or approximately 264.4 m³/h. Substituting that flow back into density × volumetric flow × specific heat × range recovers the 1,680 kW duty, subject to rounding.


This calculation reconciles temperatures, flow and heat. It does not prove that a particular tower can achieve 29.5°C. The manufacturer's selection must use the project's entering wet-bulb, water flow and temperature conditions. The nominal rating in the brochure is only a reference point.


6. Make the supplier comparison reviewable


  • State evaporator capacity and condenser heat rejection separately, both in kW, at the same operating condition.

  • Identify compressor input, heat recovery and any additional loop heat included in the boundary.

  • Record the supplier's definition of a ton and the conditions attached to its nominal capacity.

  • Reconcile water flow, range and fluid properties, then obtain the actual site-condition selection.

  • Keep capacity allowance and operating-cell assumptions visible instead of burying them in conversion factors.


For a broader workflow connecting chillers, condenser water and cooling-tower selection, use the paid Chilled Water System Design Handbook. Its worked design material can support the surrounding review while the equipment manufacturer's selection establishes the actual duty. The immediate deliverable is simple: one heat balance, explicit units and no unexplained “tons.”



Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page