top of page

Multi-Zone AHU Ventilation: Recheck Critical-Zone Efficiency at Part Load

Oct 22
5 min read
Conceptual cutaway of a supply duct branching to three office zones.

Illustrative engineering scene. The worked calculation below uses explicit example inputs.


A multi-zone AHU can need more outdoor-air intake when one zone reaches minimum primary airflow, even though the total supply volume has fallen. The zone with the greatest outdoor-air requirement relative to its primary airflow can govern the system's ventilation efficiency. Using one efficiency value from the peak-cooling schedule can conceal that change.


This worked review uses the single-supply alternative-procedure relationships published in ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 62.1-2016 with Addendum f, approved in June 2018, cross-checked against ASHRAE's September 2021 ventilation training. It is an illustrative calculation, not a compliance assessment or a statement about the edition adopted for any project. Confirm the governing edition, permitted procedure and complete requirements separately.



Define a system that the equations actually describe


The example is a single-duct VAV system with common AHU-level mixing. It has three zones, no fan-powered terminals, no secondary recirculation and no transfer-air or separate ventilation supply. All volume flows use a consistent reference basis. Zone air-distribution effectiveness is stipulated as one, and no occupancy diversity is taken in this example.


The zone outdoor-air requirements are given inputs: A needs 160 L/s, B needs 100 L/s and C needs 140 L/s. They are not generated from an occupancy category or a copied ventilation-rate table. With the stated assumptions, the uncorrected system intake, Vou, is 400 L/s. In a real project, document how population, area, diversity and distribution effectiveness produced the inputs before performing this downstream calculation.


Xs = Vou / Vps. Zpz = Voz / Vpz. Evz = 1 + Xs − Zpz. Ev is the lowest Evz among the zones. The calculated outdoor-air intake is Vot = Vou / Ev. Vps is system primary airflow; Vpz is a zone's primary airflow; Voz is that zone's outdoor-air requirement.


Keep Xs and the actual intake fraction separate. Xs uses the uncorrected 400 L/s in its numerator. The actual intake fraction for a scenario is Vot/Vps, after the efficiency correction. Substituting Vot into the Xs equation creates a different calculation and can make the spreadsheet look internally consistent while no longer following the stated method.



Calculated outdoor intake is 428.6, 687.0, 764.4 and 530.6 L/s for four full-flow, part-load, critical-zone-low and revised-minimum scenarios.

The critical low-flow zone can raise the intake requirement; increasing its minimum reduces the illustrative requirement from 764.4 to 530.6 L/s.


Begin with the all-high-flow snapshot


Let primary flows to A, B and C be 800, 1000 and 1200 L/s. The total is 3000 L/s. The corresponding zone fractions Zpz are 0.2000, 0.1000 and 0.1167. Zone A is critical because it has the largest ratio and therefore the lowest calculated zone efficiency.


Xs = 400 / 3000 = 0.13333. Critical-zone Ev = 1 + 0.13333 − 0.20000 = 0.93333. Vot = 400 / 0.93333 = 428.57 L/s. The resulting intake fraction is 428.57 / 3000 = 14.29%.


This is a snapshot, not proof of a satisfactory VAV design. In particular, the high zone flow used here does not establish what happens when the same zone reaches its minimum while other zones continue demanding substantial cooling airflow.


Reduce all three primary flows


Now set A to 250 L/s, B to 650 L/s and C to 900 L/s. Keep the stipulated outdoor-air requirements unchanged. The system primary flow becomes 1800 L/s. Zone A's ratio increases to 160/250 = 0.6400, while B and C are approximately 0.1538 and 0.1556.


Xs = 400 / 1800 = 0.22222. Ev = 1 + 0.22222 − 0.64000 = 0.58222. Vot = 400 / 0.58222 = 687.02 L/s. Intake fraction = 38.17%.


Carrying the earlier 428.57 L/s intake into this snapshot would miss the new model result by approximately 258.45 L/s. The smaller total supply has not justified a smaller outdoor intake, because the critical zone's primary airflow fell disproportionately. This conclusion follows from the particular demands and flow combination; it is not a universal trend for every building.


Check mixed loads, not only all-high and all-low conditions


Retain A at 250 L/s but return B and C to 1000 and 1200 L/s. Total primary airflow is now 2450 L/s. The critical ratio remains 0.6400, but Xs falls to 400/2450 = 0.16327. That gives Ev = 0.52327 and Vot = 764.43 L/s, higher than either previous snapshot.


The official addendum distinguishes the lowest zone primary airflow from the highest expected system airflow at the design condition under review. That distinction matters: an all-minimum-flow calculation can miss the controlling combination. Establish credible coincident conditions from the design and control sequence, rather than indiscriminately combining unrelated maxima and minima.



Test a revised critical-zone minimum


Raise A's illustrative minimum to 400 L/s while B and C remain at 1000 and 1200 L/s. Recalculate the system total as 2600 L/s. Do not retain 2450 L/s after changing the zone flow: that would mix two different operating states in one efficiency calculation.


Xs = 400 / 2600 = 0.15385. Zp,A = 160 / 400 = 0.40000. Ev = 1 + 0.15385 − 0.40000 = 0.75385. Vot = 400 / 0.75385 = 530.61 L/s.


The revised minimum reduces the calculated intake from 764.43 to 530.61 L/s, but increases system primary flow by 150 L/s. It is an option to evaluate, not an automatic energy improvement. Check terminal controllability, zone comfort, reheat consequences, acoustics, fan duty and the other load conditions before adopting it.


Independently check the mixed-load arithmetic


A simplified normalized-contaminant balance can check the 764.43 L/s result. For this check only, assume perfect mixing, zero outdoor concentration, one common allowable concentration increment of one, no removal and source rates numerically equal to the three stipulated zone demands. This is not an exposure assessment or an application of the standard's Indoor Air Quality Procedure.


Return concentration = 400 / 764.43 = 0.52327. Supply concentration = (1 − 764.43 / 2450) × 0.52327 = 0.36000. Zone A concentration = 0.36000 + 160/250 = 1.00000. Zones B and C give 0.46000 and 0.47667.


This independent balance explains the critical-zone result without assuming that every litre of primary air is newly introduced outdoor air. It also checks that intake correction and zone ratios were applied consistently. It does not validate the chosen source model for real contaminants.


Finish with a scenario-based review record


  • State the standard edition, method and permitted system configuration.

  • Preserve the origin of each zone requirement and every diversity or effectiveness assumption.

  • Evaluate minimum critical-zone flow with credible coincident system flows.

  • Recalculate both zone ratios and system totals after every minimum-flow revision.

  • Verify that the proposed intake can actually be delivered and controlled under the reviewed operating conditions.


Get the Ventilation & Exhaust Design Handbook for a connected engineering workflow covering airflow requirements, duct losses, fan selection and controls. Use it as a professional reference alongside the project's governing ventilation standard and approved design basis.




Continue the calculation review




Sources and calculation basis


Primary references checked on 22 October 2026. The worked examples and diagrams are original illustrative calculations, not manufacturer selections or project approvals. Apply the stated limitations and the requirements governing the actual project.




Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page